Grand Theft Auto IV Released amid Controversy
April 29, 2008 02:17 PM
by
findingDulcinea Staff
April 29 marks the release of Grand Theft Auto IV, the latest version of a video game that many suggest encourages violent behavior.
30-Second Summary
Grand Theft Auto IV, one of the most highly anticipated video games ever released, has met with emphatic resistance from parents and lawmakers. Enthusiasts say the game will provide “hours upon hours of the most immersive and interactive entertainment ever seen," and there are reports of people scheduling vacations from work simply to play the game.
But the Parents Television Council is urging retailers not to stock the game, as its violent and pornographic content could have a negative effect on children. Although the game is intended for adults and is rated M for Mature by the ESRB, there is concern that children will still be able to get their hands on the game that serves to “teach children how to kill.”
Attorney Jack Thompson argues that playing previous versions of Grand Theft Auto inspired his client Devin Moore to murder three police officers. “The video game industry gave him a cranial menu that popped up in the blink of an eye, in that police station," says Thompson. “And that menu offered him the split-second decision to kill the officers, shoot them in the head, flee in a police car, just as the game itself trained them to do."
Thus far, the only country to censor the new version of the game is Australia. Parents can review the game content on What They Say and make their own determination whether the game is appropriate for their children.
But the Parents Television Council is urging retailers not to stock the game, as its violent and pornographic content could have a negative effect on children. Although the game is intended for adults and is rated M for Mature by the ESRB, there is concern that children will still be able to get their hands on the game that serves to “teach children how to kill.”
Attorney Jack Thompson argues that playing previous versions of Grand Theft Auto inspired his client Devin Moore to murder three police officers. “The video game industry gave him a cranial menu that popped up in the blink of an eye, in that police station," says Thompson. “And that menu offered him the split-second decision to kill the officers, shoot them in the head, flee in a police car, just as the game itself trained them to do."
Thus far, the only country to censor the new version of the game is Australia. Parents can review the game content on What They Say and make their own determination whether the game is appropriate for their children.
Headline Links: ‘What is Grand Theft Auto, and why does it cause such controversy?’
The highly anticipated release of Grand Theft Auto IV has inspired some avid game users to take off an entire week of work to play the game, says Tim Ingham, who edits the U.K.-based gaming industry news site MCV. Ingham says the game will provide "hours upon hours of the most immersive and interactive entertainment ever seen." But some argue that previous games in the series encourage disturbing real-life behavior. Despite such criticisms, Take-Two, the game’s parent company, has already made $70 million from the franchise.
Source: The Independent UK
Grand Theft Auto IV’s fictional Liberty City strongly resembles New York and the game “seems to be daring critics to attack its nakedly authentic setting,” reports The Phoenix. Florida attorney Jack Thompson calls the game “a murder simulator for violence against women, cops, and innocent bystanders.” The fourth and most realistic-looking version of the game only adds fuel to the fire.
Source: The Phoenix (Boston)
Reactions: Game must be kept away from minors
According to the Ars Technica Web site, the Parents Television Council wants retailers to agree not to sell the game at all, but if they do, “they should not market the game to children in any way, nor should they display the game where minors can see it.” In a January 2008 posting on the same Web site, writer Ben Kuchera refers to data indicating that it’s easier for children to purchase R-rated movies than M-rated video games, and argues that there is currently no research definitively linking violent video games to negative behavior.
Source: Ars Technica
Background Links: Grand Theft Auto blamed in cop killer case
In 2005, attorney Jack Thompson argued that his 18-year-old client, Devin Moore, accused of murdering three police officers, was taught to kill by playing Grand Theft Auto. When he was apprehended by the police for suspected car theft, Moore told them cryptically, “Life is like a video game. Everybody’s got to die sometime." Sentenced to death later that year, Moore was still appealing his case as of late 2007.
Source: CBS News
Thompson also recently addressed a controversial letter to the mother of Strauss Zelnick, Take-Two’s chairman, that refers to the Moore case: “experts note that the recent plethora of cop killings is caused in part by your darling son's entrepreneurial energy.”
Source: VNUNET.com
Related Topic: Game censored in Australia
To the dismay of devoted gamers, Grand Theft Auto IV was censored in Australia. Users will have to order the game from abroad if they want to play it in its complete form, and “angry Australian gamers are declaring revocation of their pre-orders.”
Source: My Gen
Reference Links: Game content and rating system
What They Play, a gaming site, describes the structure and content of Grand Theft Auto IV. The game takes place in the fictional Liberty City, which is modeled after New York City. According to the site, it is a “‘sandbox’ game design, meaning that the player is free to experiment with what the game world has to offer, much like playing with toys in a sandbox.” The game is also rated M by the ESRB, which means it contains “Blood,” “Intense Violence,” “Partial Nudity,” “Strong Language,” “Strong Sexual Content,” and “Use of Drugs and Alcohol.”
Source: What They Play
The Entertainment Software Ratings Board explains the video game rating system.

