Jack the Ripper Unearthed in South Africa
by
findingDulcinea Staff
“The Fox and the Flies” is receiving excellent reviews from the serious press. The book argues that the notorious Ripper was a Polish émigré called Joseph Lis.
30-Second Summary
Joseph Lis, a known rapist who was probably executed sometime around 1918, came to the attention of author Charles van Onselen through an old newspaper article found in the Johannesburg Public Library.
Van Onselen spent the next 30-odd years compiling his case against Lis, which is now published as "The Fox and the Flies."
Lis stands accused of the murder and mutilation of five female prostitutes in the East End neighborhood of Whitechapel, London, in 1888: the crimes attributed to Jack the Ripper.
While the Ripper was not the first serial killer in history, Casebook—a Web site devoted to the case—says that the rise of the press gave him the notoriety he holds today.
“Every day the activities of the Ripper were chronicled in the newspapers as were the results of the inquiries and the actions taken by the police,” Casebook writes. “It was the press coverage that made this series of murders a ‘new thing.’”
Joseph Lis was born in Poland in 1868, and later changed his name to Joseph Silver. According to van Onselen, Joseph Silver’s misogyny, criminal record and movements all point to his being Jack the Ripper.
London Review of Books writer Charles Nicholl says that the links van Onselen establishes are “tenuous and speculative, but perhaps tenuous and speculative are as good as we are going to get in a 120-year-old case that from the outset generated so many conflicting accounts and theories.”
Mystery writer Patricia Cornwell spent millions of dollars trying to prove that British painter Walter Sickert was the Ripper. She claimed that DNA found on Sickert’s belongings matched that discovered on letters apparently written by Jack the Ripper.
Casebook disputes Cornwell’s argument, noting that kind of DNA used can only narrow possible matches to a segment of the population, not an individual person.
Van Onselen spent the next 30-odd years compiling his case against Lis, which is now published as "The Fox and the Flies."
Lis stands accused of the murder and mutilation of five female prostitutes in the East End neighborhood of Whitechapel, London, in 1888: the crimes attributed to Jack the Ripper.
While the Ripper was not the first serial killer in history, Casebook—a Web site devoted to the case—says that the rise of the press gave him the notoriety he holds today.
“Every day the activities of the Ripper were chronicled in the newspapers as were the results of the inquiries and the actions taken by the police,” Casebook writes. “It was the press coverage that made this series of murders a ‘new thing.’”
Joseph Lis was born in Poland in 1868, and later changed his name to Joseph Silver. According to van Onselen, Joseph Silver’s misogyny, criminal record and movements all point to his being Jack the Ripper.
London Review of Books writer Charles Nicholl says that the links van Onselen establishes are “tenuous and speculative, but perhaps tenuous and speculative are as good as we are going to get in a 120-year-old case that from the outset generated so many conflicting accounts and theories.”
Mystery writer Patricia Cornwell spent millions of dollars trying to prove that British painter Walter Sickert was the Ripper. She claimed that DNA found on Sickert’s belongings matched that discovered on letters apparently written by Jack the Ripper.
Casebook disputes Cornwell’s argument, noting that kind of DNA used can only narrow possible matches to a segment of the population, not an individual person.
Headline Link: ‘Who Was He?’
South African researcher Charles van Onselen argues in his latest book, “The Fox and the Flies,” that the true identity of late 19th century killer Jack the Ripper was Joseph Silver. Born Joseph Lis in Kielce, Poland, in 1868, Silver got his start in crime in London. He then committed a string of petty offenses in New York before heading to South Africa and South America.
Source: London Review of Books
Background: Jack the Ripper
Jack the Ripper was the first serial killer in a major metropolitan area. He emerged at a time when the press was growing in stature and populace growing in literacy. The Web site Casebook, which describes itself as “the world's largest public repository of Ripper-related information,” says the press played a tremendous role in conjuring the notoriety that still surrounds Ripper’s crimes.
Source: Casebook
Jack the Ripper was most likely a single white male living in the same Whitechapel district of London as many of his victims. According to Crime Library, his familiarity with the neighborhood may have helped him evade capture. The five women he killed in Whitechapel were probably not his first victims. Because his victims were all prostitutes, his initial murders could have gone unreported or uninvestigated.
Source: Crime Library
Opinion & Analysis: Circumstantial evidence or DNA?
William Grimes, book reviewer for The New York Times, argues that while van Onselen gives Joseph Lis “grotesque master criminal status,” he was “hardly a Napoleon of crime.” Grimes says that van Onselen’s hypothesis that Lis is Jack the Ripper “rests on a heap of circumstantial evidence” relying heavily on the idea that Lis drew inspiration from Chapter 23 of the Book of Ezekiel, which warns “the whores of Egypt that their noses and ears would be cut off.”
Source: The New York Times
Murder mystery writer Patricia Cornwell argues in her book “Portrait of a Killer: Jack the Ripper, Case Closed” that Victorian painter Walter Sickert was the killer. Forensic scientists hired by Cornwell matched DNA found on letters apparently written by the Ripper to that found on a number of Sickert’s possessions. However, the Web site Casebook refutes Cornwell’s analysis, saying that the type of DNA analyzed is not unique and narrows the sample size to a percentage of the population rather than an individual.
Source: Casebook
Related Links: Books on Jack the Ripper
Charles van Onselen’s book “The Fox and the Flies: The Secret Life of a Grotesque Master” is available at findingDulcinea’s bookstore.
Source: findingDulcinea’s Bookstore
Patricia Cornwell’s book “Portrait of a Killer: Jack the Ripper, Case Closed” is also available at findingDulcinea’s bookstore.
Source: findingDulcinea’s Bookstore







