Andrew Stuart/AP
British Police Rethink Rape Investigation Techniques
July 10, 2008 07:01 AM
by
Devin Felter
In proposing specialist squads to investigate rape cases, British police are taking a sober look at the country’s low rate of rape conviction, and its victim care.
30-Second Summary
In 2007, a 24-year-old British man was convicted of raping a 10-year-old girl. He was sent to prison for two years, the judge basing his sentence on the belief that the 10-year-old had “dressed provocatively.” Although this sentence was appealed and eventually extended to four years, British rape cases have been indicative of a social bias purporting that women bring rape upon themselves.
Roughly 6 percent of reported rapes in England and Wales lead to a conviction, compared to 13 percent in the United States. A British Crime Survey has also discovered that only 15 percent of rape crimes are reported to the police.
John Yates, Metropolitan Police Assistant Commissioner, is spearheading efforts to create rape inquiry squads. He contends that more specialists, particularly in the initial investigation stages, would improve evidence-gathering and the efficacy of accusations.
“Every force has a responsibility to ensure that every single officer who comes into contact with a rape victim is supportive and believes the victim,” he says. “It may only take the raising of an eyebrow to cause her to lose courage.”
But these changes will be difficult to enact. Opinion polls reveal that one-quarter to one-third of Britons believe that a drunk or provocatively dressed rape victim is responsible for her attack.
“It is a national scandal that thousands of victims of rape have no access to justice,” says Katherine Rake, director of the Fawcett Society. “In many cases women face a culture of disbelief, and delayed responses lead to the loss of vital evidence.”
Roughly 6 percent of reported rapes in England and Wales lead to a conviction, compared to 13 percent in the United States. A British Crime Survey has also discovered that only 15 percent of rape crimes are reported to the police.
John Yates, Metropolitan Police Assistant Commissioner, is spearheading efforts to create rape inquiry squads. He contends that more specialists, particularly in the initial investigation stages, would improve evidence-gathering and the efficacy of accusations.
“Every force has a responsibility to ensure that every single officer who comes into contact with a rape victim is supportive and believes the victim,” he says. “It may only take the raising of an eyebrow to cause her to lose courage.”
But these changes will be difficult to enact. Opinion polls reveal that one-quarter to one-third of Britons believe that a drunk or provocatively dressed rape victim is responsible for her attack.
“It is a national scandal that thousands of victims of rape have no access to justice,” says Katherine Rake, director of the Fawcett Society. “In many cases women face a culture of disbelief, and delayed responses lead to the loss of vital evidence.”
Headline Links: ‘Postcode lottery of rape conviction’
The Fawcett Society, a women’s equality group, published a map this week illustrating the disparity of rape conviction efforts across Britain. Certain law enforcement districts are five times less likely to convict potential rapists than in other districts. “The fact that only 5.7 percent of reported rapes leads to a conviction is a national scandal,” says policy officer Sarah Campbell. “The government needs to drive cultural change within the criminal justice system, to ensure that rape is given a high priority by every police force in the country and to invest in a national network of rape crisis centres.”
Source: The BBC
Eighteen of 43 British police centers reported a decline in rape conviction from 2004 to 2006. Although Cleveland rape cases led to successful prosecution at a ratio of 1 to 7, the number of convictions is under 10 percent in most locations. In Leicestershire, the number dwindled to fewer than 1 in 35. Vera Baird, the solicitor-general, said that “these disturbing figures reveal that women face a postcode lottery when reporting rape to the police.”
Source: Times Online
Opinion & Analysis: Blaming the victim
In the 1970s, the rate of rape conviction was more than 30 percent, reports the Washington Post. But the increase of “date rape” cases, where the rapist and victim are acquainted with one another, has gradually led to a conflicted jury. Kerim Fuad, a barrister who has experience with rape cases, said that in “date rape” trials, the jury has difficulty in deciding whom to believe, even in cases where the evidence of rape is compelling.
Source: The Washington Post
“So you’d think the government would want to give out the message that rape is not justified in any circumstances, wouldn’t you?” asks Anne Wollenberg. But an advertisement on Directgov, the official British government Web site for citizens, sends a different message: “Would you get in with a man you just met? One in three rapes reported happens when the victim has been drinking.” Wollenberg says that the advertisement makes its point, that one reduces the chances of being raped by remaining sober. “But it makes its point badly. And it implies that if you’re drunk and you’re the victim of rape then you’re to blame.”
Source: The Guardian
Related Topics: Rape in the news
A survey published on July 2 revealed that three members of the Welsh Assembly have been raped. Of the eight anonymous responses, five said that they knew of someone who had been a victim of sexual assault. None of these instances were reported to the police.
Source: The Independent
The U.S. Supreme Court recently ruled that the death penalty is unconstitutional in cases of child rape, overturning a Louisiana Supreme Court ruling.
Source: findingDulcinea
Condoleezza Rice was invited to lead a UN discussion on the issue of rape as a weapon of war on June 19. MONUC advocates are concerned with the lack of attention given to rape in the Democratic Republic of Congo, where 60 percent of the perpetrators are thought to have AIDS.



